Audit and Challenge
An audit asks 3Dogs to check a draft. A challenge asks a fresh panel to rule on objections to an earlier 3Dogs answer. Both are in beta: findings may include false alarms and the audit can miss errors, so check every finding against its source. Treat any audit finding as a lead to check against its source, not as a verdict.
How to ask
Say it to your assistant in plain words; it sends ask_3dogs with a prefix on the question.
Audit. "Audit this with 3Dogs." Your assistant sends question = "AUDIT: " + the original question and puts the draft to check in context. Offer it when stakes are high or you want a second look.
Challenge. "Challenge that 3Dogs answer." Your assistant sends question = "CHALLENGE: " + the original question and puts the earlier 3Dogs answer plus your numbered objections in context. Use it when a 3Dogs result looks incorrect, incomplete or overconfident.
Both directions. For high-stakes work, mutual checking is recommended: your assistant can challenge a 3Dogs result, and 3Dogs can audit your assistant's final draft before it affects a decision, a report or compliance. You can also run a question in one assistant and audit the whole thing in another (for example run it in Claude and audit it in Grok, or the reverse); your 3Dogs memory follows you between assistants.
What comes back
Audit: a VERDICT (SOUND / SOUND WITH FIXES / UNSOUND), ERRORS, UNSUPPORTED claims, and MISSING points.
Challenge: a fresh panel rules on each objection (HOLDS / REVISED / UNCLEAR) and returns a corrected summary.
Citations and the tier line follow the same rules as any other answer (see Asking).
The limits, as plainly as the live text states them
- The audit is in beta. Its findings may include false alarms and it can miss errors, so check them against sources.
- We are refining the engine before formal launch."
- It missed sums inside documents, rules that had changed recently, and one rule stated slightly wrong."
- It was one small test, not a benchmark."
- The 11 November round was weaker than the 30 October test. Dated results, including misses, are on https://3dogs.ai/connectors/proof/
- 3Dogs Nexus is not advice, and AI can make mistakes; check important facts.
Try it yourself
- Self-check test: ask a hard question you already know the answer to, then say "audit your answer with 3Dogs". If you disagree, say "challenge 3Dogs" and a fresh panel rules on it: holds, revised or unclear.
- Freshness test: ask your assistant alone, with no connectors, "What were the most important developments in [your industry] in the last seven days?", then "run the same question in 3Dogs". It passes if 3Dogs cites at least one source dated within the last seven days that the assistant's answer missed.
Last updated 11 November 2026